The flavor combination makes this Lemon Impossible Pie an old fashioned favorite you will love and it couldn’t be easier.

The minute we spied Lemon Impossible Pie we knew we were on to a winner! The comments from those that have made it are nothing short of glowing. One thing’s for sure, you’re going to love it!

What people love specifically is that it’s a quick and easy recipe and also, self crusts. It is similar to a pastry texture and the coconut actually rises to the top during the cooking process. This forms a delicious crispy lid. So, let’s take a look at what you need to make this dessert at home.

Lemon Impossible Pie Recipe Ingredients

  • 3/4 Cup Sugar
  • 4 Eggs
  • 1/2 Cup Butter
  • 2 Cups Milk
  • 1 Teaspoon Vanilla
  • Half a Juiced Lemon
  • 1/2 Lemon Zested
  • One Cup Coconut Flakes
  • 1/2 Cup Flour

How To Make Lemon Impossible Pie Video

Impossible Lemon Pie Recipe by GreaterGood

Our friends at Greater Good are the creators behind this recipe. We only recently shared their No-Bake Lemon Box Cake and had excellent feedback.

We highly recommend that you take a minute to view the video, this way you will get the best possible result. To watch, click Play above ^

This fabulous recipe comes to us from 12 Tomatoes and they have a full printable recipe on their site. Find the details here.

Want More Lemon Recipes?

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Privacy policy  ·  Cookie policy.

Mini Butternut Snap Cookie Cheesecakes

Everything is better when it's mini! These bite-size Lemon Cheesecakes are made using a store-bought packet biscuit as a base and they taste amazing. These have been hugely popular for WHOot Contributor Wendy's Kitchen but b warned, they are addictive!

Best Salted Caramel Fudge Recipe

Learn the secret to making creamy, dreamy, Salted Caramel Fudge with this very easy and super popular recipe that you will love. You only need a handful of ingredients and we have a video to show you how.

Gordon Ramsay’s Famous Scrambled Eggs Recipe

Gordon Ramsay's Scrambled Eggs has had 48 million views on youtube and boy are they good! You will love to learn the secret ingredient that he uses and also see the way he cooks them. Everyone raves about his eggs and you simply have to make them! Get the recipe and watch the video now.

The Best Ever 5-Star Tuna Casserole Recipe

Everyone's loving this 5 star rated Tuna Noodle Casserole that's made from scratch. It's the ultimate comfort food minus the canned soup and it's ohhh so delicious. This recipe gets rave reviews and it will be a new favorite in your home. Watch the quick video now.

Flourless 3 Ingredient Banana Pancake Recipe

These 3 ingredient banana pancakes have been an internet sensation and it's the secret ingredient that makes them fluffy and delicious! It's the perfect use for your over-ripe bananas and healthy too. We have the recipe and quick video to show you how. View now.

Best Ever Strawberry Lemonade Recipe

This Strawberry Lemonade whips up in a heartbeat and it's so delicious and refreshing. In fact, it's perfect for when you have guests drop in! This has been a hugely popular recipe with our community and it's very pretty on your table too. Watch the quick tutorial now.

Dave’s Easy And Delicious 3 Ingredient Donuts

These 3 ingredient donuts are a sweet treat that can't be beat. You will love this delicious recipe that gets rave reviews and it couldn't be easier! We have a video tutorial to show you how.

You’ll Love This 4 Ingredient Creme Brulee

OMGeeee! We're so excited to share this easy and delicious 4 ingredient Creme Brulee recipe. We know that you are going to love this famous French Custard and Caramel creation. Watch the tutorial and learn how now.

Easiest Homemade Condensed Milk Recipe

Never buy store-bought again! We were stoked to discover that all you need is 2 simple ingredients to make homemade Condensed Milk. Now you can learn the tricks and tips to making your own at home. Grab the easy recipe and watch the video too.

Dr. Bergs Healthiest Bread In The World Recipe

If you love your bread, you won't be able to wait to try this healthiest bread in the world recipe from the famous Dr. Eric Berg. This recipe has gone viral and it's Gluten Free and Flour Free and tastes great. Get the details now and watch the quick video tutorial while you're here.

The Best 4 Ingredient 10 Minute Puff Pastry

It's easy to make your own Puff pastry in just 10 minutes using 4 ingredients and one of them is water! Never buy store-bought again! Watch the video tutorial and check out the 4 easy desserts you can make. Don't miss these genius ideas!

Best Magic Custard Cake Recipe

This delicious Magic Custard Cake is an old tried and true recipe that you simply have to make. You get 3 layers. A crust on the bottom a custard pie style middle and a cake on top. It is beyond delicious and super easy. Get the recipe now, we've included a quick video too!