Magic Custard Cake Is An Old Fashioned Family Fave

Everyone is a rave for Magic Custard Cake and you will be too. It’s a cross between a souffle’ and a custard tart and it’s incredibly delicious and you will absolutely love it.

This delicious Magic Custard Cake is a taste sensation. It’s easy to make when you know how and Wendy from Wendy’s Kitchen Table is in the house to show us how!

It gets rave reviews on Facebook. This recipe is one batter that becomes 3 layers and there’s a reason that everyone goes mad for.

Magic Custard Cake Ingredients

4 eggs (Whites separated from the yolks), room temp
1 tsp vanilla extract
¾ cup sugar
125g (4.4oz) butter, melted
¾ cup plain flour
2 cups milk, lukewarm
icing sugar, for dusting

Magic Custard Cake Video Tutorial

We have included a tutorial from Wendy’s Kitchen Table to show you how to recreate this recipe. Click Play above to view ^

advertisement - keep scrolling

Magic Custard Cake Instructions

Preheat oven to 160˚C (320F) or 140˚C (280F) Fan-forced. Line a square cake pan with baking paper.

Separate the eggs. Add the egg whites to a mixer and beat until egg whites are stiff. Place beaten egg whites in a bowl and set aside. Beat egg yolks and sugar until light in color. Add butter and vanilla.

Beat 2 minutes. Add flour and mix it until fully incorporated. Slowly add the milk and beat until everything is well mixed together. Add the egg whites, a third at a time and gently fold them in using a whisk, repeat until all egg whites are folded in.

Pour batter into baking dish and bake for approx 60 minutes or until the top is lightly golden. (Wendy has a hot oven and it was ready in 40 minutes).

It will feel set when you press it. Cool and dust heavily with icing sugar.( I leave it in the fridge overnight and cut it the next morning.) Store in a container in the fridge. This recipe is not suitable to freeze.

More Wendy Recipes To Try

If you’d like to see more great ideas from Wendy’s Kitchen Table you can visit her Facebook page or see more of her recipes below!

2 other great versions of Magic Custard Cake can be found on En Paper Blog and also on Hugs and Cookies

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
Privacy policy  ·  Cookie policy.

Mint Chocolate Mousse With Peppermint Crisp Crumble

Mint Chocolate Mousse With Peppermint Crisp Crumble Topping - does it get any better sounding than that? This holiday treat not only tastes incredible, it's a lovely looking dessert to serve your guests! Get Phoodies fab recipe now.

The Most Delicious No Bake Lemon Icebox Cake Recipe

This Lemon Icebox Cake Recipe has been an internet sensation and it's NO BAKE and easy to make. We have a quick video to show you how to make this dreamy, creamy dessert that will be a new family favorite.

The Best No Bake Vanilla Slice 4 Ingredient Recipe

It's the famous 4 Ingredient No Bake Vanilla Slice recipe that has taken the world by storm and now you can make your own incredibly delicious custard slice. We've included a video tutorial too. Don't miss this easy and incredibly yummy recipe. It's a prize winner for sure!

Yummy 3 Ingredient No Bake Apricot Balls Recipe

These 3 Ingredient Apricot Coconut Balls are NO Bake and easy to make! They are a delicious sweet treat and an old family favourite you are going to love. Check out the short video tutorial too! You won't want to miss this recipe.

Best 5 Ingredient Apple Strudel Muffins Recipe

With only 5 ingredients, the creator says these are the BEST Apple Strudel Muffins that you will ever bake. You will be head over heels for the traditional crumbly texture and they are guaranteed to be a new family fave. We have the recipe and video to show you how.

Easy Breezy Bacon And Egg Broccoli Slice Recipe

Do we ever have an easy and delicious recipe to share with you today. This Bacon Egg Broccoli Slice is to die for and it's quick and easy to make and tastes great. Whether it's a lazy lunch or a quickie dinner, this is an absolute winner and did we mention Gluten Free!

Honey Rice Bubble Slice Is An Old Fashioned Favorite

A delicious twist on an old classic, this Honey Rice Bubble Slice can be made for a snack, for dessert, and even gluten-free!

Learn To Make Your Own Homemade Honeycomb

You won't believe how easy you can make your own Homemade Honeycomb. WHOot Contributor Gemma is here to share her fail proof recipe. Watch her video now.

Better Than Store Bought 2 Ingredient Condensed Milk

Why buy when you can make your own at home! We were stoked to discover all you need is 2 simple ingredients to make your own Condensed Milk. Now you can learn the tricks and tips to making your own at home. Check out the quick video and see the results first hand!

Learn How To Make A Gorgeous Cupcake Bouquet

Oh My! Take your decorating to the moon by learning how to create these gorgeous cupcake bouquets that make wonderful gifts for family and friends. Watch the video tutorial and check out all the amazing versions now. You will love what you see!

How To Make Delicious Melt In The Mouth Pot Roast

We've tried this recipe recently and it is the most amazing melt in the mouth slow cooker roast we have ever had. It's a one-pot wonder with all the trimmings! We've got the Pioneer Woman's Recipe for you to check out too. Watch the video too for helpful tips and tricks.

These Potato Rolls Are Melt In Your Mouth Delicious

Are you ready to learn how to make the yummiest, fluffiest, melt in the mouth Potato Rolls? We have the easy video tutorial and recipe to show you how and you are guaranteed to love them. Find out now.